This week, the American Craft Spirits Association (ACSA) launched its annual Craft Spirits Data Project, which revealed that craft-distillery closures outpaced openings for the first time in 2025. Ahead of the report’s launch, Global Drinks Intel caught up with the trade group’s CEO, Emily Pennington (below).
How are the US’s craft distillers holding up in 2026?
It’s a hard time to be an independent distiller in the US right now, and I imagine globally as well. The things that they’re up against are: retail buyers are picking up fewer new products, and they have higher expectations for performance when they do take on new ones; distributors in the US are reducing staff, they’re cutting divisions, they’re narrowing their focus on the biggest brands and their portfolios; and then, of course, consumers are moderating consumption habits – they’re still drinking, but they’re drinking differently to how they did pre-pandemic.
Altogether, it’s challenging times. But I don’t like to necessarily focus on the ‘woe is us’, because what’s really wonderful about this category is that in times like these, craft distillers do what they do best and what they’re best equipped to do, which is adapt.
It wouldn’t be realistic of me to say that the category is thriving, but there are definitely pockets of success and brands within this category that are succeeding. There are over 2,000 craft distillers. It isn’t a monolith, by any means.
Why are distributors narrowing their focus to larger brands? Is it due to extra brands looking for new homes after the collapse of Republic National Distributing Co?
Distribution is far and away the greatest challenge the craft distillers are facing right now, among a handful of others that I already mentioned.
RNDC’s collapse has really caused havoc for the entire wholesale tier in the US. That ‘s one issue. I saw a great stat that essentially said that, even if you’re planning a distributor transition that you chose, a distiller can end up with a five-to-15% volume loss in the short term. Imagine you’re with the second-largest distributor in the US and it just disappears almost overnight. There’s no orderly transition.
I’d say that few, if any, of the small distillers who were with RNDC have fully recovered at this point. They’re still in triage mode, trying to find new routes of distribution.
The other pain point is that the big distillers are focusing on their largest brands. And I get it! They have the highest volume. They have the highest revenues. They have the most power when it comes to negotiating strategic relationships with their distributors. Of course they’re going to focus on those.
There’s more incentive to focus on those bigger brands, and there’s more risk involved if they don’t.
Why are retail buyers picking up fewer new products?
There are two factors, and it’s almost a chain of events. The first is consumer buying trends: US consumers are still buying alcohol, but they’re becoming more intentional with what they purchase … which of course affects what the retailers are putting on their shelves.
The other factor is that the US is still normalising inventory levels post-Covid. In 2020 and 2021, both distributors and retailers were ordering based on the trends that we saw in Covid. Everyone across the board got surprised around 2024 when those trends slowed down drastically. We’re still working through what’s normal post-Covid.
In the data you collect, what is the most significant marker or indicator of how craft distillers are performing?
The most important indicator is at the very end of the report, when we look at how much craft distillers are reinvesting in their businesses annually, and the number of people that they employ.
There’s a direct correlation between how well their businesses are doing and how much they reinvest annually, and the data for both points saw a pretty significant drop in 2025.
That was going to be my next question!
The challenging thing about releasing a report that’s a year behind is that conditions [today] are slightly different. They aren’t drastically different, but they’re slightly different in 2026. People sometimes forget what the industry was like in 2025, which was much worse than 2026 has been.
In what sense?
Sales and volumes were down more last year than they look like they’re going to be in 2026. That certainly doesn’t mean that they’re not down …, but it’s to a lesser degree. On an anecdotal level, I found that in 2025, craft distillers were still realising that the market was going to be challenging for a while, and there was more confusion and concern about what’s going to happen.
This year, I see a lot more adapting to those conditions. It almost feels like we’ve moved from a period of mass confusion and worry to an acceptance of this is what it is, an we’re going to dig in and adapt to the cards that have been dealt to us.
In 2024 and 2025, so much of the industry was saying, ‘Is this cyclical or is it long term?’ Now, at the end of 2026, we’re learning that this is a fundamental shift that’s going to last for a little while.
We’re not just going to magically come right back out of it.
What are the longer-term impacts of distillers rowing back on investment?
For our annual report, we ask: ‘How much did you reinvest in your business in the calendar year 2025?’ and then we ask: ‘For what reason did you reinvest?’ It’s always been interesting to me that the top answer has always been: ‘We’re reinvesting in our market channels to meet demand.’
We don’t have any additional follow-ups on that, but I can only assume that that means investing in entering new markets, for the most part. I don’t necessarily think the actual long-term effect is detrimental, but it does back up the data we’re seeing that post-Covid, craft distillers are finding more success in sales at their own tasting rooms than they did pre- Covid.
It’s almost like a tale of two chapters: pre-Covid, craft distillers were expanding slowly but surely into new regions, markets and distributors. Post-Covid, because market access has gotten more challenging, we’re seeing them retrench into their own markets and tasting rooms to ride out this tumultuous period.
The number of active craft distilleries in the US declined again in 2026 (above), according to the report. Is the industry over the worst?
I do worry about it continuing. We haven’t seen any slowing in the closure rate yet. There’s a new announcement every couple of weeks, and it’s disheartening, and I don’t see it slowing until we have some sort of macro change – whether that’s in consumer demand or market access for these guys.




